When building a portfolio, it’s easy to focus on returns, but smart investors know that net returns are what really count. That’s where taxation plays a crucial role. In Europe, where tax laws vary by country, understanding how capital gains and dividends are taxed can help you strategically tilt your portfolio to keep more of your profits.
This guide breaks down the differences between capital gains and dividends, compares their tax treatment in key EU countries, and offers actionable tips to optimise your investment strategy.
📈 What Are Capital Gains and Dividends?
Capital Gains: Profits made when you sell an asset (like stocks or real estate) for more than you paid for it.
Dividends: Regular payouts that companies make to shareholders from their profits, usually in cash or additional stock.
💸 Key Differences in Tax Treatment (and Why It Matters)
Tax Feature | Capital Gains | Dividends |
|---|---|---|
When Taxed | Upon sale of the asset | When received |
Timing Flexibility | High – you control when to sell | Low – automatically taxed when paid |
Compound Growth Impact | Delayed taxation favours compounding | Regular taxation can slow reinvestment growth |
Country Variation | Sometimes tax-exempt after a holding period | Often subject to flat or progressive tax |
🇪🇺 Tax Snapshot by Country (2024-2025)
Country | Capital Gains Tax | Dividend Tax |
|---|---|---|
Germany | 25% flat + solidarity surcharge | Same rate applies |
France | 30% flat (includes social charges) | Same rate applies |
Italy | 26% flat | 26% flat |
Spain | 19-28% progressive | 19-28% progressive |
Netherlands | Taxed on “deemed return” (Box 3 system) | 15% withholding, more if taxed as income |
Belgium | 0% on most capital gains for individuals | 30% on dividends |
💡 Winner: Capital Gains
In most European countries, capital gains either have lower tax rates, more control over timing, or exemptions (especially if holding long-term). Dividends, while steady, are taxed as soon as they hit your account.
🔍 Strategic Considerations
Dividend-focused portfolios may face drag from annual taxes, even if reinvested.
Growth-focused portfolios (capital appreciation) allow you to defer taxes—potentially compounding wealth more efficiently.
ETFs and Accumulating Funds (especially UCITS-compliant) often reinvest dividends internally, shielding you from immediate taxation in some jurisdictions.
Tax treaties may reduce withholding taxes on foreign dividends—check your local tax office or advisor.
📊 Case Study: Capital Gains vs. Dividends in Germany
Investor A chooses a dividend-heavy ETF yielding 4%. Receives €1,000 annually and pays 26.375% tax.
Investor B picks an accumulating ETF. No tax for 10 years; capital gains taxed only when sold.
Result: Investor B grows wealth faster due to tax-deferred compounding.
📌 Real ETF Examples
Dividend-focused ETFs:
iShares Euro Dividend UCITS (IDVY)
SPDR S&P Euro Dividend Aristocrats (SPYW)
Growth-focused ETFs:
iShares MSCI World Acc
Vanguard FTSE All-World Acc
🧾 Tax Example (Germany):
ACC ETFs = tax-deferred until sale.
DIST ETFs = taxed yearly on distributions.
🌡️ Inflation Impact
Capital gains: Often grow with inflation, and tax is deferred.
Dividends: Fixed cash payouts are taxed yearly—real returns erode in inflationary periods.
Real return = Nominal return – taxes – inflation.
🧠 Wealth Building Stage Strategy
Younger investors: Prioritise growth and capital gains for long-term compounding.
Older investors or income-seekers: Blend in dividends, but inside tax wrappers.
🛠️ Tax Optimisation Tips
Use tax-advantaged accounts (like Germany’s Freistellungsauftrag or France’s PEA) to shield gains or dividends.
Prioritise capital growth assets in taxable accounts and dividend assets in tax-advantaged wrappers.
Use accumulating (ACC) ETFs to avoid dividend distributions and delay taxation.
Harvest losses strategically to offset gains.
Be country-aware: Belgium and Luxembourg investors may find capital gains more attractive due to exemption rules.
📋 ACC vs. DIST ETFs: What’s Better?
ETF Type | Cash Flow | Annual Tax | Compounding | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Accumulating | No | Deferred | Strong | Long-term, taxable accounts |
Distributing | Yes | Immediate | Slower | Tax-free wrappers, retirement income |
💼 Withholding Tax Reclaim Tips
Most countries apply withholding tax on foreign dividends (15–30%).
You can reclaim part of it through your local tax office.
Example: German investors with US stocks can file W-8BEN to reduce US withholding from 30% to 15%.
🔧 Future Feature: After-Tax Return Calculator
Coming soon: a free interactive tool to estimate your after-tax, after-inflation returns based on:
Your country of residence
ETF type (ACC/DIST)
Investment amount & horizon
👉 Stay tuned via Wealth’s Ark Newsletter.
✅ Action Checklist
Know your country’s capital gains & dividend tax laws
Use accumulating ETFs when possible
Reclaim foreign dividend tax (e.g., W-8BEN)
Use wrappers like PEA or tax-free allowances
Rebalance yearly and harvest losses
Match ETF type to account and goals
Consider inflation-adjusted real returns
❓ FAQs
Q: Are all capital gains taxed equally in Europe?
A: No. Some countries (e.g., Belgium) exempt capital gains altogether, while others (e.g., Spain) use progressive rates.
Q: Are dividend taxes always withheld automatically?
A: Yes, especially for foreign dividends. Check your tax treaty and reclaim options.
Q: Should I avoid dividend-paying assets?
A: No—but use them inside tax-advantaged accounts to reduce yearly tax drag.
Q: What’s the difference between ACC and DIST ETFs?
A: ACC ETFs reinvest internally, often deferring tax; DIST ETFs pay out cash, which is taxed immediately.
Q: Is tax planning worth it if I only invest small amounts?
A: Yes—compounding small tax advantages over time makes a big difference.
🧠 Final Verdict: Capital Gains Are Generally More Tax-Friendly
While dividends offer immediate returns, capital gains tend to be more flexible, deferred, and often lower-taxed, especially in countries like Belgium or when using accumulating funds. A growth-oriented strategy, enhanced by tax planning, may yield stronger long-term results after taxes.
📥 Want a Personalised Investment Tax Strategy?
Subscribe to Wealth’s Ark and get a free Portfolio Tax Optimisation Guide for European Investors (PDF), plus bonus content on:
Smart use of accumulating vs. distributing ETFs
Cross-border tax tricks (legally!)
How to allocate dividends and growth assets by account type
👉 Subscribe here and copy our investing strategy on eToro while building your own!